The increasing prevalence of the
Internet and social networking sites has broken down existing geographical
barriers, leading to the condensation of time and space. The Internet has
provided an accessible platform for all kinds of activities, ranging from ibanking
to online video conference call, thus bringing about great ease to our daily
lives. However, such ubiquitous use can result in the infringement of privacy,
harassment, circulation of false information and many other criminal acts that
will affect the wellbeing of individuals. The online community was never a safe
place to be in in the first place.
The imperative issue at hand
regarding the Internet and social networking sites would be its impacts on
youths in today’s society. The widespread use of social networking platforms
among the adolescents nowadays has led to their unprecedented detachment from
social life. The pervasive use of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and other social
media platforms among the technological savvy teenagers of the 21st century
can inevitably lead to the creation of an apathetic society. The depravation of
social life means that youths nowadays are unable to receive social cues and
interact with people on a face-to-face basis. As such, relevant parties,
especially the family, friends and schools, have to take measures to
reintegrate teenagers into society once again.
According to Sproull and Kiesler
(1985) (Bargh and McKenna, 2004), computed-mediated communication (CMC) is an “impoverished
form of communication”. It will reduce the availability of social cues, resulting
in the production of a “behaviour that is more self-centered and less socially
regulated than the usual”. This can have negative impacts on social
interaction. The over-reliance on the Internet as a tool of communication will
eventually erode youth’s ability to carry out a proper face-to-face conversation.
This makes it even harder for youths to integrate into a society that thrives
on real time interaction. What makes the matter worst is that “social media
sites can make it more difficult for youths to distinguish between the
meaningful relationships they foster in the real world and the numerous casual
relationships formed through social media” (Jung, n.d.). It gives rise to this
false sense of connection that will only encourage the detachment of youths
from the real physical world.
No proper solutions have actually
been given to curb this surging problem. There have however been a lot of
suggestions online, ironically, to inform parents and hopefully youths about
the negative effects of the Internet and social networking sites. These
articles urged parents to save their children by engaging them in activities
that will allow them disconnect from the online world. Parents can encouraged
children to pick up a new hobby that does not involve the Internet, or carry
out family bonding activities like exercising or playing board games that can
serve to distract youths from the contrived online world. Schools on the other
hand can emphasise on the disconnection from the online community by actively
encouraging students to take part in school-based activities such as
representing the school in a sport or performing art, organising field trips
and even camps. Such a variety of programmes will focus on the engagement of
youths, which will then serve to forge a greater interaction between youths and
the society. Youths will also be able to gain more appreciation towards their
surroundings, instead of constantly immersing themselves in the intangible
online world.
However, the above given
suggestions have long been used and applied before. Schools do provide
activities, camps and field trips for students, and many people do value family
bonding session. Yet, youths are still spending way too much time on the
Internet and social networking sites. This problem could be largely due to the
fact that the Internet is easily accessible on their mobile phones. In 2012 and
2013, a game, know as the ‘Phone stack game’, became popular in many parts of
the world. The game requires diners to stack their phones in the middle of the
table, and whoever touches their device first will have to foot the bill (Tell,
2013). Such practice will not only allow youths to momentarily disengage from
the online world, but will also effectively give them the chance to conduct
real time communication with their friends and forge a more substantial
relationship with their peers. As such, influences from friends will also
encourage the detachment from the virtual world. Perhaps, what we need to do
most is to set aside solid rules and regulations that will serve the purpose of
reintegrating youths back into the society, instead of just advising them and
the relevant parties on what they should do.
Youths’ lives are heavily reliant
on the Internet as technology advances. It has become almost impossible for
people to isolate themselves from the online world, but it is possible for them
to acknowledge the importance of forming tangible relationship with one
another. Such awareness is vital in making sure that youths will not detach
from the society. The creation of such awareness will them be the most useful
solution to curb this impending problem.
(828 words)
References:
Bargh, J.A., McKenna,
K.Y.A. (2004). The internet and social life. Annual Review of Psychology, 55, 573-590.
Jung, B. (n.d.). The negative
effects of social media on society and individuals. Small Business. Retrieved from http://smallbusiness.chron.com/negative-effect-social-media-society-individuals-27617.html
Sproull, L., Kiesler, S. (1985).
Reducing social context cues: electronic mail in organizational communication. Management Science, 11, 1492-1512.
Tell, C. (2013, September 20).
Step away from the phone! The New York
Times. Retreived from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/22/fashion/step-away-from-the-phone.htm
1. What do you like the best about the ideas in this essay? Be specific. (precise vocabulary, cohesive/linked ideas, clear/easy to follow discussion, convincing, effective reasoning/argument, well-developed ideas, well-supported topic sentences, understandable transitions, etc.)
ReplyDeleteGood use of vocabulary. Your thesis is very specific and to the point. It is very easy to read your essay as your points transits smoothly from one paragraph to the next. The problem is clearly stated as well .
2. Is there a clear, narrowly-focused problem presented in the essay? Is it contextualized in the intro? Is it expressed well in the thesis?
Yes, the problem is clearly stated and very focused from the second paragraph. However I think that perhaps you can mention the problem briefly in the introduction? When I first read the introduction, I immediately thought that you were going to talk about cyber-crimes instead of social media leading to youths being detached from social life.
3. How well is the first solution described? How effectively is that solution evaluated?
It is well described, however I think you can provide a bit of evidence here, maybe find evidences of those online suggestions teaching parents what to do.
4. How well is the second solution described? Is it effectively connected to a positive outcome?
The second solution is well described as well. The “phone stack game” ultimately connects to a positive outcome and seems practical yet effective.
5. Are there any ideas in the essay that need further development? Which parts of the essay require further elaboration?
I think maybe you can add in abit of your own ideas on how to solve the problem or improve the existing solutions. Because as of now it seems like your solutions are all existing ideas.
6. Does the writer effectively use outside source material to illustrate the problem and/or the solutions?
Yes, there are quite a number of outside source materials to support you points
7. What is your impression of the flow of the content?
I think the flow of content is smooth with good transitions from each point.
8. Are there any ideas in the essay that are not clear or that you find confusing? Underscore/ highlight these.
No, except for the introduction. I was initially a little bit confused because it seemed as though you were heading into an essay about cyber crimes.
9. Are the citations used in this essay appropriate? Are the reporting verbs effectively used? Does the reference list adhere to the APA guidelines?
Yes
Yes, good citations, reporting verbs and correct referencing list.
10. Can you give a couple specific suggestions for how the writer could most improve this essay?
- I think from the introduction you can start to steer the whole essay towards youths detachment from social life instead of talking about cyber-crimes because it can be a little bit confusing for readers
Hi Wei Ting :)
ReplyDelete1. What do you like the best about the ideas in this essay? Be specific. (precise vocabulary, cohesive/linked ideas, clear/easy to follow discussion, convincing, effective reasoning/argument, well-developed ideas, well-supported topic sentences, understandable transitions, etc.)
Your essay is well-organized with the use of transitions to move from one idea to another. I am assuming that your thesis is "The widespread use of social networking platforms among the adolescents nowadays has led to their unprecedented detachment from social life."? Maybe the first paragraph should describe some problems of the detachment from social life because as what Jocyelyn said, the cyber-crime part is confusing.
2. Is there a clear, narrowly-focused problem presented in the essay? Is it contextualized in the intro? Is it expressed well in the thesis?
Yes. The problem is about social detachment due to social media.
3. How well is the first solution described? How effectively is that solution evaluated?
She has mentioned that no proper solutions were implemented, and gave some examples of existing possible solutions that have circulated on the internet.
4. How well is the second solution described? Is it effectively connected to a positive outcome?
She mentioned that no proper solutions are available. In my opinion, the "solutions" such as internet guides and phone stack games are solutions that are not legitimatised, instead, created by the public community, which makes it hard to evaluate accordingly.
5. Are there any ideas in the essay that need further development? Which parts of the essay require further elaboration?
Maybe she can come up with a new solution, taking into account the existing solutions from the public community.
6. Does the writer effectively use outside source material to illustrate the problem and/or the solutions?
Yes. There is a significant number of external sources.
7. What is your impression of the flow of the content?
Flow of content is smooth and well-organized.
8. Are there any ideas in the essay that are not clear or that you find confusing? Underscore/ highlight these.
Same as Joycelyn, introduce social detachment instead of cyber crimes at the start.
9. Are the citations used in this essay appropriate? Are the reporting verbs effectively used? Does the reference list adhere to the APA guidelines?
Yes. Good use of reporting verbs, reference list adheres to APA guidelines.
10. Can you give a couple specific suggestions for how the writer could most improve this essay?
Refer to 8.
Thank you Wei Ting, keep up the good work :)
Zimin